学术人员跨国迁移研究评述:从个体属性向网络关系演进

摘要
图/表
参考文献
相关文章 (15)

全文: PDF (7066 KB) HTML (1 KB)
输出: BibTeX | EndNote (RIS)

摘要学术人员跨国迁移作为新兴的交叉领域,越来越受到学术界和管理层的关注。本文通过学术人员跨国迁移理论从个体决策向国家循环演进、学术人员跨国迁移“推-拉”动力机制、学术人员跨国迁移知识与社会“网络”效应以及学术人员跨国迁移流失与回流特征等方面的文献评述,提出学术人员跨国迁移研究正在逐步从个体属性向网络关系演进。应该看到,在向网络关系演进的过程中,还存在“网络”经验研究缺乏、机构层面研究不足、“关系”因素关注较少等几个方面的薄弱环节,有待于进一步研究拓展。

	服务

	把本文推荐给朋友
	加入我的书架
	加入引用管理器
	E-mail Alert
	RSS
	作者相关文章
	孙玉涛
	国容毓

关键词 ：学术人员, 跨国迁移, 网络, 文献综述

Abstract：As a new interdiscipline,the transnational migration of academic staff has attracted more and more attention from the academia and management layer.It raises that the study of transnational migration of academic researchers is gradually evolving from the individual attributes to the network relationship by reviewing literatures of evolution of transnational migration of academic staff from the individual decision-making to the national-circulation,the“push-pull”dynamic mechanism,knowledge and social network effect and characteristics of immigrants and return migrants.Attention should be paid to these weakness spots in the following studies:empirical research on the“network”,the researches in institutional level and concerns on “relationship” factors.

Key words： Academic staff Transnational migration Network Literature review

收稿日期: 2017-05-02

PACS:

C962

基金资助:国家自然科学基金面上项目:“基于‘人员—机构’匹配的学术人员跨国迁移网络研究:模型、结构与机制”(71673035)。

作者简介: 孙玉涛(1982-),男,江苏人,大连理工大学管理与经济学部教授;研究方向:创新管理与战略、科技管理与政策等。

引用本文:

孙玉涛,国容毓. 学术人员跨国迁移研究评述:从个体属性向网络关系演进[J]. 中国科技论坛, 2018(2): 154-162.
Sun Yutao,Guo Rongyu. A Review on Transnational Migration of Academic Staff:Shifting from the Individual Attributes to the Network Relationship. , 2018(2): 154-162.

链接本文:

http://www.zgkjlt.org.cn/CN/Y2018/I2/154

[1] BARUFFALDI S H,LANDONI P.Return mobility and scientific productivity of researchers working abroad:the role of home country linkages[J] .Research policy,2012,41(9):1655-1665.
[2] CERVANTES M,GUELLEC D.The brain drain:old myths,new realities[J] .OECD observer,2002(230):40.
[3] OECD.International mobility of the highly skilled[M] .OECD Publishing,2002.
[4] MAIER G,KURKA B,TRIPPL M.Knowledge spillover agents and regional development:spatial distribution and mobility of star scientists[J] .DYNREG(Dynamic Regions in a Knowledge-Driven Global Economy),2007(17):1-34.
[5] 朱军文,李奕嬴.国外科技人才国际流动问题研究演进[J] .科学学研究,2016,34(5):697-703.
[6] ZWEIG D,WANG H.Can China bring back the best? The Communist Party organizes China's search for talent[J] .The China quarterly,2013(215):590-615.
[7] 孙玉涛,张帅.海外青年学术人才引进政策效应分析——以“青年千人计划”项目为例[J] .科学学研究,2017,35(4):511-519.
[8] CAO C.China's brain drain at the high end:why government policies have failed to attract first-rate academics to return[J] .Asian population studies,2008,4(3):331-345.
[9] COMMANDER S,KANGASNIEMI M,WINTERS L A.The brain drain:curse or boon? A survey of the literature[M] //BALPWIN R E,WINTERS L A.Challenges to globalization:analyzing the economics.University of Chicago Press,2004:235-278.
[10] STARK O,HELMENSTEIN C,PRSKAWETZ A.A brain gain with a brain drain[J] .Economics letters,1997,55(2):227-234.
[11] STARK O,HELMENSTEIN C,PRSKAWETZ A.Human capital depletion,human capital formation,and migration:a blessing or a “curse”[J] .Economics letters,1998,60(3):363-367.
[12] STARK O.Rethinking the brain drain[J] .World development,2004,32(1):15-22.
[13] DUSTMANN C,FADLON I,WEISS Y.Return migration,human capital accumulation and the brain drain[J] .Journal of development economics,2011,95(1):58-67.
[14] ACKERS L.Moving people and knowledge:scientific mobility in the European union1[J] .International migration,2005,43(5):99-131.
[15] SAXENIAN A L.From brain drain to brain circulation:transnational communities and regional upgrading in India and China[J] .Studies in comparative international development(SCID),2005,40(2):35-61.
[16] 冯慰容,冼国明.人力资源国际流动的趋衡性分析[J] .中国软科学,2003(10):101-105.
[17] 陆根书,彭正霞.高引学者跨国学术流动及对其成长的影响[J] .研究生教育研究,2011(1):62-67.
[18] BEINE M,DOCQUIER F,RAPOPORT H.Brain drain and human capital formation in developing countries:winners and losers[J] .The economic journal,2008,118(528):631-652.
[19] 王培根,牛敏.浅析高技术人才的国际流动[J] .科学学研究,2002,20(3):262-265.
[20] MEYER J B.Policy implications of the brain drain's changing face[J] .Science and development network,2003,3(213).
[21] EDLER J,FIER H,GRIMPE C.International scientist mobility and the locus of knowledge and technology transfer[J] .Research policy,2011,40(6):791-805.
[22] BEINE M,DOCQUIER F,ODEN-DEFOORT C.A panel data analysis of the brain gain[J] .World development,2011,39(4):523-532.
[23] RAPOPORT H.Who is afraid of the brain drain?A development economist's view[J] .Law,ethics and philosophy,2016(4):119-131.
[24] ANDERSON J E.The gravity model[J] .Annual review in economics,2011,3(1):133-160.
[25] BEINE M,BERTOLI S,FERN NDEZ-HUERTAS Moraga J.A practitioners’ guide to gravity models of international migration[J] .The world economy,2016,39(4):496-512.
[26] BEINE M,PARSONS C.Climatic factors as determinants of international migration[J] .The scandinavian journal of economics,2015,117(2):723-767.
[27] BACKHAUS A,MARTINEZ-ZARZOSO I,MURIS C.Do climate variations explain bilateral migration? A gravity model analysis[J] .IZA journal of migration,2015,4(1):1-15.
[28] 孙健,纪建悦,王丹.海外科技人才回流的规律研究[J] .中国软科学,2005(8):6-10.
[29] WEINBERG B A.Developing science:scientific performance and brain drains in the developing world[J] .Journal of development economics,2011,95(1):95-104.
[30] FU M.A cultural analysis of China's scientific brain drain:the case of Chinese immigrant scientists in Canadian academia[J] .Journal of international migration and integration,2014,15(2):197-215.
[31] ADSERA A,PYTLIKOVA M.The role of language in shaping international migration[J] .The economic journal,2015,125(586).
[32] CAO C,SUTTMEIER P R.China's new scientific elite:distinguished young scientists,the research environment and hopes for Chinese science[J] .The China quarterly,2001,168:960-984.
[33] 谢勇,陈念宁.我国高等教育涉外引智工作的发展、问题与对策[J] .自然辩证法研究,2013,29(7):67-72.
[34] TIAN F.Skilled flows and selectivity of Chinese scientists at global leading universities between 1998 and 2006[J] .Journal of science and technology policy in China,2013,4(2):99-118.
[35] 马万华,麻雪妮,耿玥.“千人计划”学者回归的动因、学术优势与挑战[J] .清华大学教育研究,2013(1):94-97.
[36] 高子平.学术相关性维度的海外理工科留学人才回流意愿研究[J] .自然辩证法研究,2014,30(6):74-81.
[37] ZWEIG D,FUNG C,HAN D.Redefining the brain drain:China's diaspora option[J] .Science technology and society,2008,13(1):1-33.
[38] 谢荣艳,葛鹏.基于组织层面的科研机构人员流动影响因素研究[J] .中国科技论坛,2017(1):129-135.
[39] ZEITHAMMER R,KELLOGG R P.The hesitant hai gui:return-migration preferences of U.S.-educated Chinese scientists and engineers[J] .Journal of marketing research,2013,50(5):644-663.
[40] QIN F.Global talent,local careers:circular migration of top Indian engineers and professionals[J] .Research policy,2015,44(2):405-420.
[41] ALBERTS H C,HAZEN H D.There are always two voices:international students′intentions to stay in the United States or return to their home countries[J] .International migration,2005,43(3):131-154.
[42] 高子平.全球经济波动与海外科技人才引进战略转型[J] .科学学研究,2012,30(12):1810-1817.
[43] COE N,BUNNELL T.‘Spatializing’ knowledge communities:towards a conceptualization of transnational innovation networks[J] .Global networks,2003,3(4):437-456.
[44] JNS H.‘Brain circulation’and transnational knowledge networks:studying long‐term effects of academic mobility to Germany,1954—2000[J] .Global networks,2009,9(3):315-338.
[45] GIBSON J,MCKENZIE D.Scientific mobility and knowledge networks in high emigration countries:evidence from the pacific[J] .Research policy,2014,43(9):1486-1495.
[46] JONKERS K,CRUZ-CASTRO L.Research upon return:the effect of international mobility on scientific ties,production and impact[J] .Research policy,2013,42(8),1366-1377.
[47] 陈代还,段异兵,潘紫艳.二元关系网络对海归科学家产出的影响[J] .中国科技论坛,2015(9):143-147.
[48] LI F,MIAO Y,YANG C.How do alumni faculty behave in research collaboration? An analysis of Chang Jiang Scholars in China[J] .Research policy,2015,44(2):438-450.
[49] 杨张博,高山行,刘小花.近朱者赤:基于社会网络分析方法的归国者跨国社会资本转移研究[J] .社会,2015,4(35):177-198.
[50] ADAMS Jr R H.International migration,remittances,and the brain drain:a study of 24 labor-exporting countries[R] .World bank policy research working paper N.3069,2003.
[51] 刘俊婉.高被引科学家人才流动的计量分析[J] .科学学研究,2011,29(2):192-197.
[52] WANG X,MAO W,WANG C,et al.Chinese elite brain drain to USA:an investigation of 100 United States national universities[J] .Scientometrics,2013,97(1):37-46.
[53] 张松涛,关忠诚.科技人才的教育经历研究——以中国科学院杰出青年为例[J] .中国科技论坛,2015(12):132-137.
[54] 高子平.海外科技人才回流意愿的影响因素分析[J] .科研管理,2012,33(8):89-105.
[55] ZWEIG D.Competing for talent:China's strategies to reverse the brain drain[J] .International labour review,2006,145(1-2):65-89.
[56] 曹聪.中国的“人才流失”“人才回归”和“人才循环”[J] .科学文化评论,2009(1):13-32.
[57] 董洁林.“天生全球化”创业模式探讨:基于“千人计划”海归高科技创业的多案例研究[J] .中国软科学,2013(4):26-38.
[58] 赵卫华.海归博士与本土博士职业成就比较:基于全国博士质量调查的统计分析[J] .中国高教研究,2010(11):47-50.
[59] 鲁晓,洪伟,何光喜.海归科学家的学术与创新:全国科技工作者调查数据分析[J] .复旦公共行政评论,2014(2):7-25.
[60] 余广源,范子英.“海归”教师与中国经济学科的“双一流”建设[J] .财经研究,2017,43(6):52-65.
[61] SUN Y,LIU F.Measuring international trade-related technology spillover:a composite approach of network analysis and information theory[J] .Scientometrics,2013,94(3):963-979.