Abstract：Patent aggregating companies,fostering patents operation by acquiring patents and aggregating large patent portfolios,can be divide into eight types of business model and four types of strategy.Patent aggregating companies not only bring chances of innovative development,but also monopoly threats the competition order of IP market.In Europe and America,rich experiences have been accumulated on the aspects of review forms,regulation methods and regulation procedures of patent aggregation anti-monopoly for many years.At present,Chinese enterprises are frequently suffering from the attack of patent aggregator in the international market,but no warning system is established against patent aggregator so far in China.In order to make up the deficiency of anti-monopoly laws in the field of intellectual property,it is of great importance to make the full use of regulations and laws,establishing and improving relevant security mechanism,and enhancing the quality of patent so as to avoid the vicious lawsuits.
[1]RTHER F.Patent aggregating companies:their strategies,activities and options for producing companies[M].Springer Fachmedien Wiesbaden,2011. [2]EWING T,FELDMAN R.The giants among us[J].Stanford technology law review,2012(1):1-64. [3]The EPO's Economic and Scientific Advisory Board.ESAB statement on patent aggregation and its impact on competition and innovation policy[EB/OL].(2015-04-14).http://www.epo.org/news-issues/news/2015/20150414.html. [4]RTHER F,ZIEGLER N,BADER M.Patent aggregating companies:motives,activities and a classification.6th European Conference on Innovation and Entrepreneurship[C].Aberdeen,Scotland,2011-09-15. [5]KRECH A,RTHER F,GASSMANN O.Profiting from invention:business models of patent aggregating companies[J].International journal of innovation management,2015(3):1-27. [6]孟奇勋,张一凡,范思远.主权专利基金:模式、效应及完善路径[J].科学学研究,2016(11):1655-1662. [7]PAPST D.NPEs and patent aggregators-new,complementary business models for modern IP markets[J].The licensing journal,2012(10):1. [8]凯文·G·里韦特,戴维·克兰.尘封的商业宝藏 启用商战新的秘密武器:专利权[M].陈彬,杨时超,译.北京:中信出版社,2002. [9]TEECE D.Managing intellectual capital[M].Oxford University Press,2000. [10]袁晓东,孟奇勋.开放式创新条件下的专利集中战略研究[J].科研管理,2010(5):157-163. [11]CHESBROUGH W.Open business models:how to thrive in the new innovation landscape[M].Boston:Harvard Business Review Press,2016. [12]Federal Trade Commission.To promote innovation:the proper balance of competition and patent law and policy[J].Berkeley technology law journal,2004,19(3):860-883. [13]张志成.专利形态及许可方式演变对创新的影响及政策应对——兼论NPE等现象的发生[J].电子知识产权,2014(6):26-30. [14]LEMLEY M,MELAMED D.Missing the forest for the trolls[J].Columbia law review,2013(12):2117-2189. [15]KELLEY A.Practicing in the patent marketplace[J].The university of chicago law review,2011,78(1):115-137. [16]HEGARTY R.Intellectual Ventures:why the patent system needs aggregators[EB/OL].(2013-01-09).http://www.intellectualventures.com/insights/archives/intellectual-ventures-why-the-patent-system-needs-aggregators. [17]ORR J.Patent aggregation:models,harms and the limited role of antitrust[J].Berkeley technology law journal,2013(4):525-568. [18]张志成.专利集中管理的机遇与挑战[J].电子知识产权,2012(5):20-21. [19]刘斌强.NPEs:反垄断面临的挑战[J].科技与法律,2013(4):14-19. [20]郭德忠.美国关于专利权集中的反垄断规制的启示[J].云南行政学院学报,2009,11(2):152-155. [21]CARRIER M.U S district court upholds antitrust action against patent troll(Intellectual Ventures,Capital One)[J].National competition laws bulletin,2015(5):1-5. [22]CARRIER M.Patent assertion entities:six actions the antitrust agencies can take[J].CPI antitrust chronicle,2013(1):2. [23]刘淼.非专利实施实体的是与非——美国专利制度的变革及其启示[J].知识产权,2014(12):65-68. [24]吴艳.论美国打击专利投机的政策和举措[J].科学管理研究,2014(2):117-120. [25]易继明.美国《创新法案》评析[J].环球法律评论,2014(4):146-166. [26]Federal Trade Commission.Patent assertion entity activity:an FTC study[EB/OL].(2016-10-06).https://www.ftc.gov/reports/patent-assertion-entity-activity-ftc-study. [27]中科院知识产权信息.美国司法部和联邦委员会修订知识产权许可的反垄断指南[EB/OL].(2017-02-17).http://www.ciplawyer.cn/articleview/article_view_21137.htm. [28]U.S.Department of Justice and the Federal Trade Commission.Antitrust guidelines for the licensing of intellectual property[EB/OL].(2017-1-12).https://www.justice.gov/atr/IPguidelines/download. [29]吴太轩.技术标准化的反垄断法规制[M].北京:法律出版社,2011:119. [30]丁茂中.论专利高价许可的反垄断规制[J].知识产权,2016(3):70-75. [31]黎运智,孟奇勋.问题专利的产生及其控制[J].科学学研究,2009(5):660-665. [32]易继明.遏制专利蟑螂——评美国专利新政及其对中国的启示[J].法律科学,2014(2):174-183. [33]NOVECK B.Peer to patent:collective intelligence,open review,and patent reform[J].Harvard journal of law & technology,2006(20):123-161. [34]杜长辉,陈勇.恶意提起专利侵权诉讼的构成要件及判定路径[N].中国知识产权报,2016-01-06(9). [35]HAGIU A,YOFFIE D.Intermediaries for the IP market[J].Harvard business review,2011(1):12.
2018, 
