Good Governance of Evidence:Principle Construction and Evidence-Based Logic for the Ethical Governance of Artificial Intelligence in the UK Public Sector
Geng Xu, Huang Miaoxin
School of Government Management,Shenzhen University,Shenzhen 518000,China
Abstract：The ethical governance of artificial intelligence is an important issue faced by the deepening of the reform of electronic governments around the world,and also a key topic discussed by the academic community.Among them,how to construct the principles of ethical governance and how to adapt to the practice of ethical management become the primary issues.The UK has explored a typical ethical governance model of AI under the concept of evidence-based governance.According to the relevant documents of AI ethics governance,this study adopts the text analysis method and summarizes the constructing evidence and the content level of AI ethics governance principles in the UK public sector.Meanwhile,this paper takes the AI and public standards review of the Committee on Standards in Public Life as an example to present and refine the evidence-based logic of“principle guidance-principle application-principle embedding”.
耿旭, 黄妙欣. 证据的善治:英国公共部门人工智能伦理治理的原则建构与循证逻辑[J]. 中国科技论坛, 2023(6): 170-179.
Geng Xu, Huang Miaoxin. Good Governance of Evidence:Principle Construction and Evidence-Based Logic for the Ethical Governance of Artificial Intelligence in the UK Public Sector. , 2023(6): 170-179.
[1]MITTELSTADT B.AI ethics-too principled to fail[DB/OL].(2019-06-16).https://arxiv.org/abs/1906.06668v1. [2]FLORIDI L.Translating principles into practices of digital ethics:five risks of being unethical[J].Philosophy & technology,2019,32(2):185-194. [3]CALO R.Artificial intelligence policy:a primer and roadmap[J].UC Davis law review,2017,51(3):399. [4]WHITTLESTONE J,NYRUP R,ALEXANDROVA A,et al.The role and limits of principles in AI ethics:towards a focus on tensions[C].Hawaii:the 2019 AAAI/ACM conference on AI,ethics,and society,2019. [5]MCNAMARA A,SMITH J,MURPHY H E.Does ACM’s code of ethics change ethical decision making in software development[C].Florida:the 26th ACM joint European software engineering conference and symposium on the foundations of software engineering,2018. [6]BRENDEL A B,MIRBABAIE M,LEMBCKE T B,et al.Ethical management of artificial intelligence[J].Sustainability,2021,13(4):1974. [7]BARNES P J.Inflammatory mechanisms in patients with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease[J].Journal of allergy and clinical immunology,2016,138(1):16-27. [8]王学军,韦林,王子琦.作为信息的证据,抑或作为证据的信息?循证视角下的政府绩效信息管理框架[J].图书与情报,2018,38(6):39-46. [9]PARKHURST J.The politics of evidence:from evidence-based policy to the good governance of evidence[M].New York:Routledge,2017. [10]孙伟平,李扬.论人工智能发展的伦理原则[J].哲学分析,2022,13(1):3-14,196. [11]潘金贵,熊用坪.人工智能介入科学证据审查判断的可行性与作用路径[J].学术交流,2022,336(3):34-45,191. [12]UPSHUR R E G,VANDENKERKHOF E G,GOEL V.Meaning and measurement:an inclusive model of evidence in health care[J].Journal of evaluation in clinical practice,2001,7(2):91-96. [13]NUTLEY S M,WALTER I,DAVIES H T O.Using evidence:how research can inform public services[M].Chicago:The University of Chicago Press,2007. [14]RYCROFT M J,SEERS K,TITCHEN A,et al.What counts as evidence in evidence-based practice[J].Journal of advanced nursing,2004,47(1):81-90. [15]张斌,潘晶.论法律与地方性知识——兼论中国法治现代化的发展模式[J].当代法学,2003,10(10):11-13,36. [16]ETZIONI A,ETZIONI O.Incorporating ethics into artificial intelligence[J].The journal of ethics,2017,21(4):403-418. [17]张玉洁.论人工智能时代的机器人权利及其风险规制[J].东方法学,2017,60(6):56-66. [18]曲纵翔,董柯欣.以算法拯救循证:“知识-权力”结构下政策终结的话语空间[J].行政论坛,2021,28(6):94-104. [19]MARMOT M G.Evidence based policy or policy based evidence[J].British medical journal,2004,328(7445):906-907. [20]PARSONS W.Modernising policy-making for the twenty first century:the professional model[J].Public policy and administration,2001,16(3):93-110. [21]SANDERSON I.Evaluation,policy learning and evidence-based policy making[J].Public administration,2002,80(1):1-22. [22]杨岩,刘志辉,张兆锋.基于循证决策理念的长三角科技创新图谱构建[J].中国科技资源导刊,2022,54(4):90-101. [23]GROL R,GRIMSHAW J.From best evidence to best practice:effective implementation of change in patients' care[J].The lancet,2003,362(9391):1225-1230. [24]GALLUCCIO M.Evidence-informed policymaking[J].Science and diplomacy:negotiating essential alliances,2021,21(2):65-74. [25]CAIRNEY P,OLIVER K.Evidence-based policymaking is not like evidence-based medicine,so how far should you go to bridge the divide between evidence and policy[J].Health research policy and systems,2017,15(1):1-11. [26]张乾友.人工智能与公共服务的规范前景[J].行政论坛,2019,26(6):115-120.
2023, 
