Abstract：Since Teece pioneered the issue of profiting from innovation in 1986,research around this topic has become increasingly prosperous.Accordingly,research contexts and conclusions have become increasingly diversified.However,the existing review articles either lack details due to their wide range or not reflect the latest progress due to their earlier publication.The topic of this review is strictly limited to the effectiveness of various appropriation strategies and their influencing factors.By intensively investigating 25 representative literatures,it is found that the disparity on the effectiveness of given appropriate strategy exceeds the consistency,while the explanatory variables are too fine-grained and lack generality.Therefore,future researches should introduce case study as a supplementary method for constructing the theoretical framework about appropriate strategy and profiting,and replace the subjective opinion survey with objective inter-variable relationship examination and treat the factors affecting the effectiveness of appropriate strategy as moderators,further refine them.
[1] 约瑟夫·熊彼特.资本主义、社会主义与民主[M].吴良健,译.北京:商务印书馆,1999. [2]ARROW K.Economic welfare and the allocation of resources for invention[M]// Nelson R R.The rate and direction of inventive activity:economic and social factors.Princeton:Princeton University Press,1962:609-626. [3]黎文靖,郑曼妮.实质性创新还是策略性创新?——宏观产业政策对微观企业创新的影响[J].经济研究,2016,(4):60-73. [4]TEECE D J.Profiting from technological innovation-implications for integration,collaboration,licensing and public-policy[J].Research policy,1986,15(6):285-305. [5]SUN Y,ZHAI Y.Mapping the knowledge domain and the theme evolution of appropriability research between 1986 and 2016:A scientometric review[J].Scientometrics,2018,116(1):203-230. [6]HALL B,HELMERS C,ROGERS M,et al.The choice between formal and informal intellectual property:A review[J].Journal of economic literature,2014,52(2):375-423. [7]吴辉凡,许治.从创新中获利:国外创新独占性问题经验研究述评[J].管理学报,2010,7(8):1197-1201. [8]HURMELINNA-LAUKKANEN P,VANHALA M,OLANDER H.Appropriability profiles-different actors,different outcomes[J].International journal of innovation management,2016,20(8):1-26. [9]COHEN W M,NELSON R R,WALSH J P.Protecting their intellectual assets:appropriability conditions and why U.S.manufacturing firms patent(or not)[R].National bureau of economic research,2000,1-50. [10]LEVIN R C,KLEVORICK A K,NELSON R R,et al.Appropriating the returns from industrial-research and development[J].Brookings papers on economic activity,1987,(3):783-831. [11]MILESI D,PETELSKI N,VERRE V.Innovation and appropriation mechanisms:evidence from Argentine microdata[J].Technovation,2013,33(2-3):78-87. [12]HARABI N.Appropriability of technical innovations:An empirical analysis[J].Research policy,1995,24(6):981-992. [13]COHEN W M,GOTO A,NAGATA A,et al.R&D spillovers,patents and the incentives to innovate in Japan and the United States[J].Research policy,2002,31(8-9):1349-1367. [14]ARUNDEL A.The relative effectiveness of patents and secrecy for appropriation[J].Research policy,2001,30(4):611-624. [15]朱爱辉,黄瑞华.技术创新成果的可占有性—来自中国的实证分析[J].科学学研究,2007(5):971-977. [16]邓宏.制造企业从产品创新中获利的实证研究[D].对外经济贸易大学,2015. [17]NEUHAUSLER P.The use of patents and informal appropriation mechanisms-differences between sectors and among companies[J].Technovation,2012,32(12):681-693. [18]AMARA N,LANDRY R,TRAORE N.Managing the protection of innovations in knowledge-intensive business services[J].Research policy,2008,37(9):1530-1547. [19]LEIPONEN A,BYMA J.If you cannot block,you better run:small firms,cooperative innovation,and appropriation strategies[J].Research policy,2009,38(9):1478-1488. [20]BLIND K,EDLER J,FRIETSCH R,et al.Motives to patent:empirical evidence from Germany[J].Research policy,2006,35(5):655-672. [21]ARUNDEL A,KABLA I.What percentage of innovations are patented? Empirical estimates for European firms[J].Research policy,1998,27(2):127-141. [22]GALLIE E P,LEGROS D.French firms′strategies for protecting their intellectual property[J].Research policy,2012,41(4):780-794. [23]PEREZ-CANO C.Firm size and appropriability of the results of innovation[J].Journal of engineering and technology management,2013,30(3):209-226. [24]GOPALAKRISHNAN S,DAMANPOUR F.Patents of generation and adoption of innovation in organizations-contingency models of innovation attributes[J].Journal of engineering and technology management,1994,11(2):95-116. [25]PAJAK S.Do Innovative firms rely on big secrets? An analysis of IP protection strategies with the CIS 4 survey[J].Economics of innovation and new technology,2016,25(5):516-532. [26]EISENHARDT K M.Building theories from case-study research[J].Academy of management review,1989,14(4):532-550.
2019, 
