Abstract：Disruptive technology can create new economic growth points and obtain the leading strategic position in research and development,which is the key to national competitiveness and international status.However,it also generates new risks and challenges such as innovation alienation,regulatory disruption,excessive obedience and information deficit.At present,China adopts a variety of incentive institutional arrangements to promote the development of disruptive technology on the macro level and tries to carry out risk-prevention oriented legislation on the medium level.However,the micro-level regulatory action based on interview cannot effectively predict the risks of disruptive technology,so it is urgent to adapt to the regulatory system. To deal with the challenge of disruptive technology,China should implement the concept of inclusive and prudent supervision,build the cooperative regulation of public and private subjects,actively promote the evolution of regulation time sequence,and then divide the regulation of disruptive technology into early stage,experimental stage,quasi-legislative stage and formal legislative stage according to problems and regulatory tasks,and apply regulatory tools with different characteristics in each stage to ensure the healthy development of disruptive technology on the premise of preventing risks.
闫海, 王天依. 论颠覆性技术对规制的挑战及其应对[J]. 中国科技论坛, 2023(1): 58-68.
Yan Hai, Wang Tianyi. On the Challenge of Disruptive Technology to Regulation and Its Responses. , 2023(1): 58-68.
[1]王舒曦.颠覆性技术创新应着眼于三个“更加突出”[N].学习时报,2020-10-21(6). [2]CORTEZ N.Regulating disruptive innovation[J].Berkeley technology law journal,2014,29(1):175-228. [3]默顿.社会理论和社会结构[M].唐少杰,齐心,译.南京:译林出版社,2015. [4]COGLIANESE C,ZECKHAUSER R,PARSON E.Seeking truth for power informational strategy and regulatory policymaking[J].Minnesota law review,2004,89(2):277-341. [5]中国证券监督管理委员会网站.四部门联合约谈蚂蚁集团有关人员[EB/OL].(2020-11-02)[2022-01-10].http://www.csrc.gov.cn/csrc/c100028/c1000675/content.shtml. [6]国家市场监督管理总局网站.市场监管总局等五部门约谈特斯拉公司[EB/OL].(2021-02-08)[2022-01-10].http://www.samr.gov.cn/xw/zj/202102/t20210208_326012.html. [7]中华人民共和国交通运输部网站.约谈滴滴公司:切实履行企业主体责任 保障驾驶员和消费者合法权益[EB/OL].(2021-03-05)[2022-01-10].https://www.mot.gov.cn/jiaotongyaowen/202103/t20210305_3529787.html. [8]国家互联网信办公室网站.国家互联网信息办公室、公安部加强对语音社交软件和涉深度伪造技术的互联网新技术新应用安全评估[EB/OL].(2021-03-18)[2022-01-10].http://www.cac.gov.cn/2021-03/18/c_1617648089558637.htm. [9]求是网.金融管理部门联合约谈部分从事金融业务的网络平台企业[EB/OL].(2021-04-29)[2022-01-10].http://www.qstheory.cn/yaowen/2021-04/29/c_1127393504.htm. [10]中国政府网.8部门联合约谈10家交通运输新业态平台公司[EB/OL].(2021-05-16)[2022-01-10].http://www.gov.cn/xinwen/2021-05/16/content_5606813.htm. [11]乔舒亚·纽曼,迈克尔·豪利特.规制与时间:规制发展的时序模型[J].国际行政科学评论(中文版),2014,80(3):17-35. [12]WU T.Agency threats[J].Duke law journal,2011,60(8):1841-1858. [13]BRESSMAN L S.Beyond accountability:arbitrariness and legitimacy in the administrative state[J].Social science electronic publishing,2003,78(2):461-556. [14]STRAUSS P L.Publication rules in the rulemaking spectrum:assuring proper respect for an essential element[J].Administrative law,2001,53(3):803-850. [15]MENDELSON N A.Regulatory beneficiaries and informal agency policymaking[J].Cornell law review,2007,92(3):397-452. [16]RASO C N.Strategic or sincere?Analyzing agency use of guidance documents[J].Administrative law,2010,119:782-824. [17]冯永琴,刘乐,李文昭.域外监管沙箱机制与实践对我国产品安全监管的启示[J].中国市场监管研究,2020(11):57-60. [18]ZETZSCHE D A,BUCKLEY R P,BARBERIS J N,et al.Regulating a revolution:from regulatory sandboxes to smart regulation[J].Fordham journal of corporate and financial law,2017,23(1):31-104. [19]BEER J D,MILLAR P,MWANGI J,et al.A framework for assessing technology hubs in Africa[J].New York university journal of intellectual property & entertainment law,2017,6(2):237-277. [20]MANDELKERN GROUP.Mandelkern group on better regulation final report[R].Brussels:European Commission,2001. [21]GUBLER Z J.Experimental rules[J].Boston college law review,2014,55(1):129-180. [22]RANCHORDAS S.Innovation-friendly regulation:the sunset of regulation,the sunrise of innovation[J].Jurimetrics,2015,55(2):201-224. [23]FINN J E.Sunset clauses and democratic deliberation:assessing the significance of sunset provisions in antiterrorism legislation[J].Columbia journal of transnational law,2010,48(3):442-502. [24]GESTEL R V,DIJCK G V.Better regulation through experimental legislation[J].European public law,2011,17(3):539-542. [25]GERSEN J E,O'CONNELL A J.Deadlines in administrative law[J].University of Pennsylvania law review,2008,156(4):923-990.
2023, 
