殊途同归不同效:高层次人才跨国流动影响职业发展的实证研究

摘要
图/表
参考文献(34)
相关文章 (4)

全文: PDF (1146 KB) HTML (1 KB)
输出: BibTeX | EndNote (RIS)

摘要人才是强国之根本、兴邦之大计。跨国流动是高层次人才积累人力资本与社会资本的有效途径,学界就跨国流动如何影响高层次人才职业发展的实证研究较为鲜见。本文聚焦我国高层次人才“长江学者奖励”计划,以1998—2017年入选的1782名长江学者特聘教授为研究对象,构建长江学者特聘教授履历数据库,从学习-工作两个维度实证分析不同类别跨国流动对高层次人才职业发展的异质性影响。研究发现,不同类别的跨国流动均能影响职业发展(殊途同归),不同类别跨国流动对职业发展的影响效应差异显著(殊途异效)。从海外学习经历看,人文社科领域学者赴海外攻读博士学位、工程技术领域学者赴海外联合培养加快职业发展速度;从海外工作经历看,赴海外任教加快职业发展速度,而赴海外访问延缓入选高层次人才计划的进程。藉此本文尝试提出解释机制及对策建议。

	服务

	把本文推荐给朋友
	加入我的书架
	加入引用管理器
	E-mail Alert
	RSS
	作者相关文章
	潘虹
	唐莉

关键词 ：高层次人才, 跨国流动, 职业发展, 长江学者奖励计划

Abstract：Talent is the foundational and strategic pillar for prosperous national building.Despite that transnational academic mobility is well perceived as an effective way of accumulating social and intellectual capital,its role of impacting the career advancement of overseas returnees remains largely under-explored.Focusing on China's“Changjiang Scholar Program”this study constructs and utilizes a novel curriculum vitae dataset of 1782 Changjiang Distinguished Professors and investigates the heterogeneous effect of transnational academic mobility on the career development of China's high-level talents.This study reveals that all transnational academic mobility,regardless of types,affects career development,but such effect varies significantly by types of transnational academic mobility.In terms of overseas study experience,scholars in humanities and social sciences who have overseas PhD degree and scholars in engineering and technology who have overseas joint-degree accelerate their career development.With regard to overseas work experience,full-time working experience accelerates career development,while temporary overseas visit delays returnees'academic career development.Tentative explanations and policy implications are discussed in the end.

Key words： High-level talent Transnational academic mobility Career advancement Changjiang scholar program

收稿日期: 2022-09-01

PACS:

G316

基金资助:国家社会科学基金一般项目“高校高层次海归人才引进成效的后评估研究”(18BGL219)。

作者简介: 潘虹(1990—),女,四川中江人,助理研究员,博士,研究方向为科技人才政策、公共政策绩效。

引用本文:

潘虹, 唐莉. 殊途同归不同效:高层次人才跨国流动影响职业发展的实证研究[J]. 中国科技论坛, 2023(7): 159-169.
Pan Hong, Tang Li. Same Destination,Different Career Advancement: An Empirical Analysis of the Role of Transnational Academic Mobility Among Chinese High-level Talents. , 2023(7): 159-169.

链接本文:

http://www.zgkjlt.org.cn/CN/Y2023/I7/159

[1]JONKERS K.Mobility,productivity,gender and career development of Argentinean life scientists[J].Research evaluation,2011,20(5):411-421.
[2]MÜLLER M,COWAN R,BARNARD H.On the value of foreign PhDs in the developing world:training versus selection effects in the case of South Africa[J].Research policy,2018,47(5):886-900.
[3]李峰.海归学者的跨国资本本土化及其效果评价研究[J].华侨华人历史研究,2018(2):26-33.
[4]FISMAN R,SHI J,WANG Y,et al.Social ties and favoritism in Chinese science[J].Journal of political economy,2018,126(3):1134-1171.
[5]赵卫华.海归博士与本土博士职业成就比较:基于全国博士质量调查的统计分析[J].中国高教研究,2010(11):47-50.
[6]白新文,黄真浩.高层次青年人才成长效能的影响因素:以百人计划为例[J].科研管理,2015,36(12):138-145.
[7]ZWEIG D,CHANGGUI C,ROSEN S.Globalization and transnational human capital:overseas and returnee scholars to China[J].The China quarterly,2004,735-757.
[8]杨得前,姜群.长江学者特聘教授成长路径研究[J].高教探索,2018(5):27-35.
[9]JONKERS K,CRUZ-CASTRO L.Research upon return:the effect of international mobility on scientific ties,production and impact[J].Research policy,2013,42(8):1366-1377.
[10]LU X,MCINERNEY P B.Is it better to“stand on two boats”or“sit on the Chinese lap”? Examining the cultural contingency of network structures in the contemporary Chinese academic labor market[J].Research policy,2016,45(10):2125-2137.
[11]COMBES P P,LINNEMER L,VISSER M.Publish or peer-rich? the role of skills and networks in hiring economics professors[J].Labour economics,2008,15(3):423-441.
[12]HORTA H.Deepening our understanding of academic inbreeding effects on research information exchange and scientific output:new insights for academic based research[J].Higher education,2013,65(4):487-510.
[13]LAWSON C,SHIBAYAMA S.International research visits and careers:an analysis of bioscience academics in Japan[J].Science and public policy,2015,42(5):690-710.
[14]SHI D,LIU W,WANG Y.Has China's Young thousand talents program been successful in recruiting and nurturing top-caliber scientists[J].Science,2023,379(6627),62-65.
[15]赵俊芳,叶甜甜.“千人计划”入选者学术发展力的计量学研究:基于“985工程”高校前五批入选者[J].中国高教研究,2014(11):43-48.
[16]GILL S.The homecoming:an investigation into the effect that studying overseas had on Chinese postgraduates'life and work on their return to China[J].Compare,2010,40(3):359-376.
[17]FANGMENG T.Brain circulation,diaspora and scientific progress:a study of the international migration of Chinese scientists,1998-2006[J].Asian and pacific migration journal,2016,25(3):296-319.
[18]鲁晓.海归科学家的社会资本对职业晋升影响的实证研究[J].科学与社会,2014,4(2):49-62.
[19]CRUZ-CASTRO L,SANZ-MENÉNDEZ L.Mobility versus job stability:assessing tenure and productivity outcomes[J].Research policy,2010,39(1):27-38.
[20]ZINOVYEVA N,BAGUES M.The role of connections in academic promotions[J].American economic journal:applied economics,2015,7(2):264-92.
[21]李峰,吴蝶.高等教育背景如何影响不同学科科技人才成长——以教育部长江学者特聘教授为例[J].高等教育研究,2016,37(10):42-48.
[22]LI F,TANG L.When international mobility meets local connections:evidence from China[J].Science and public policy,2019,46(4):518-529.
[23]李峰,唐莉.海外经历能否加速职业发展:以长江学者为例[J].科研管理,2022,43(1):192-199.
[24]PARKER M,WELCH E W.Professional networks,science ability,and gender determinants of three types of leadership in academic science and engineering[J].The leadership quarterly,2013,24(2):332-348.
[25]VAN DEN BESSELAAR P,SANDSTRÖM U.Gender differences in research performance and its impact on careers:a longitudinal case study[J].Scientometrics,2016,106(1):143-162.
[26]YOUTIE J,ROGERS J,HEINZE T,et al.Career-based influences on scientific recognition in the United States and Europe:longitudinal evidence from curriculum vitae data[J].Research policy,2013,42(8):1341-1355.
[27]JONKERS K,TIJSSEN R.Chinese researchers returning home:impacts of international mobility on research collaboration and scientific productivity[J].Scientometrics,2008,77(2):309-333.
[28]YNALVEZ M A,SHRUM W M.Professional networks,scientific collaboration,and publication productivity in resource-constrained research institutions in a developing country[J].Research policy,2011,40(2):204-216.
[29]ZHANG H,PATTON D,KENNEY M.Building global-class universities:assessing the impact of the 985 projects[J].Research policy,2013,42(3):765-775.
[30]LI J.World-class higher education and the emerging Chinese model of the university[J].Prospects,2012,42(3):319-339.
[31]HUANG F.Building the world-class research universities:a case study of China[J].Higher education,2015,70(2):203-215.
[32]FOX M F,STEPHAN P E.Careers of young scientists:preferences,prospects and realities by gender and field[J].Social studies of science,2001,31(1):109-122.
[33]CUMMINGS J N,KIESLER S.Collaborative research across disciplinary and organizational boundaries[J].Social studies of science,2005,35(5):703-722.
[34]李峰,魏玉洁,孙梦园.人才项目中的“压龄”申报现象研究——长江学者奖励计划和国家杰出青年科学基金案例分析[J].重庆大学学报(社会科学版),2019,25(2):89-99.