Abstract：As the ballast stone of the construction of intellectual property power,it is of great practical significance to select and evaluate high-value patents.A four-dimensional evaluation index system of high value patents covering“economy-technology-law-strategy”was constructed.The Analytic hierarchy process(AHP)and Delphi method were comprehensively used,the index weight was given by the DPS data processing system,and the patent database of Innojoy was retrieved as the data source to screen the high value patents of permanent magnet materials.The top 10 high-value patents are presented as examples of simulated reality for reference.By comparing the DPI index,it is found that the screening results of high-value patents are highly consistent.This evaluation system and method are suitable for selecting high-value patents from massive patents,and can provide a reference patent screening method for industry related practitioners and researchers to identify technical strength,patent asset management and focus on technological innovation research.
许振亮, 王振, 高天艳. 基于层次分析法-德尔菲法的高价值专利筛选研究——以稀土永磁产业为例[J]. 中国科技论坛, 2024(1): 62-71.
Xu Zhenliang, Wang zhen, Gao Tianyan. Research on High-Value Patent Screening Based on AHP-Delphi Method ——Taking Rare Earth Permanent Magnet Industry as an Example. , 2024(1): 62-71.
[1]中共中央国务院.知识产权强国建设纲要(2021—2035年)[EB/OL].[2021-09-22].https://www.gov.cn/zhengce/2021-09/22/content_5638714.htm. [2]刘谦,姜南,王亚利,等.国内高价值专利研究热点演进与整合框架:基于SKM的可视化分析[J].科技进步与对策,2022,39(21):151-160. [3]宋凯.高校专利技术转移价值评估研究:基于熵权TOPSIS模型和梯度提升树算法[J].情报杂志,2021,40(7):52-57. [4]CHUNG P,SOHN S Y.Early detection of valuable patents using a deep learning model:case of semiconductor industry[J].Technological forecasting and social change,2020,158:120-146. [5]TRAPPEY A J C,TRAPPEY C V,GOVINDARJAN U H,et al.Patent value analysis using deep learning models—the case of IoT technology mining for the manufacturing industry[J].IEEE transactions on engineering management,2021,68(5):1334-1346. [6]朱明刚,孙旭,刘荣辉,等.稀土功能材料2035发展战略研究[J].中国工程科学,2020,22(5):37-43. [7]刘小芳,杨丽.稀土永磁专利布局态势析[J].稀土信息,2016(11):25-27. [8]冯瑞华,姜山,马廷灿,等.我国稀土永磁材料发展战略和建议[J].科技管理研究,2012,32(15):164-167. [9]马治国,谢伟,张磊.技术、法律、市场三维视角下我国药品高价值专利评估体系构建研究[J].西北大学学报(哲学社会科学版),2022,52(5):120-130. [10]谢萍,王秀红,卢章平.企业专利价值评估方法及实证分析[J].情报杂志,2015,34(2):93-98. [11]DALKEY N,HELMER O.An experimental application of the Delphi method to the use of experts[J].Management science,1963,9(3):455-468. [12]曾照云,程晓康.德尔菲法应用研究中存在的问题分析:基于38种CSSCI(2014-2015)来源期刊[J].图书情报工作,2016,60(16):116-120. [13]徐崇元,陈孟裕,金锋,等.进口食品社会关注度专家评分一致性的统计学研究[J].数理统计与管理,2021,40(1):105-116. [14]马可,于欣,李春波,等.精神分裂症认知测评简版的德尔菲法研究[J].中国心理卫生杂志,2020,34(9):736-740. [15]梁蕾.层次分析法的演进及其在竞争情报系统绩效评估中的应用[J].情报理论与实践,2015,38(12):20-24. [16]申志东.运用层次分析法构建国有企业绩效评价体系[J].审计研究,2013(2):106-112. [17]孙瑞英,李杰茹.我国政府数据开放平台个人隐私保护政策评价研究[J].图书情报工作,2022,66(12):3-16. [18]武小鹏,孔企平.基于AHP理论的数学高考试题综合难度模型构建与应用[J].数学教育学报,2020,29(2):29-34. [19]HARHOFF D,SCHERER F M,VOPEL K.Citations,family size,opposition and the value of patent rights[J].Research policy,2003,32(8):1343-1363. [20]SUZUKI J.Structural modeling of the value of patent[J].Research policy,2011,40(7):986-1000. [21]张克群,张婷,李姗姗,等.网络结构对专利PageRank与专利价值关系的门槛效应研究[J].科学学与科学技术管理,2020,41(2):66-77. [22]HALL B H,JAFFE A,TRAJTENBERG M.Market value and patent citations[J].The rand journal of economics,2005,36(1):16-38. [23]SAPSALIS E,POTTERIEA B V,NAVON R.Academic versus industry patenting:an in-depth analysis of what determines patentvalue[J].Research policy,2006,35(10):1631-1645. [24]STERZI V.Patent quality and ownership:an analysis of UK faculty patenting[J].Research policy,2013,42(2):564-576. [25]WANG S J.Factors to evaluate a patent in addition to citations[J].Scientometrics,2007(3):509-522. [26]万小丽,朱雪忠.专利价值的评估指标体系及模糊综合评价[J].科研管理,2008(2):185-191. [27]马天旗.高价值专利培育与评估[M].北京:知识产权出版社,2018. [28]孟琳.知识产权质押评估与民族地区中小企业融资[J].黑龙江民族丛刊,2012,128(3):72-75. [29]肖宏.专利许可合同中OEM、ODM条款问题浅析[J].现代经济信息,2012(10):273. [30]钱坤,张晓,黄忠全.交易情景下专利价值影响因素分析[J].科学学研究,2020,38(9):1608-1620. [31]ALLISON J R,LEMLEY M A,MOORE K A,et al.Valuable patents[J].Georget law journal,2004,92(3):435-479. [32]肖冰,许可,肖尤丹.专利审查能够影响专利维持时间吗[J].科学学研究,2018,36(7):1224-1234. [33]任声策,尤建新.中国专利生存期:基于中国在美专利数据的实证[J].管理工程学报,2012,26(4):77-83. [34]王思培,韩涛.基于随机森林算法的潜在高价值专利预测方法研究[J].情报科学,2020,38(5):120-125. [35]孙志雅,孟宇航,杨华明.黏土矿物基载药体系的研究进展[J].材料导报,2022,36(2):56-65. [36]SAATY T L.A new macroeconomic forecasting and policy evaluation method using the analytic hierarchy process[J].Mathematical Modelling,1987,9(3):219-231. [37]吴静,赵呈刚,傅晓亮.钛合金技术专利竞争趋势分析[J].特种铸造及有色合金,2013,33(11):1045-1048.
2024, 
