摘要本文以2003—2023年Web of Science核心数据库中1098篇论文为样本,采用文献计量学和可视化方法,分析科技伦理国际研究热点和演进趋势。结果发现:整体上科技伦理国际研究呈持续上升趋势,大致经历4个发展阶段。科技伦理国际研究主要研究力量分布在美国和英国,中国位列前十,虽排名比较靠后,但影响力在不断攀升。近20年的研究热点聚焦以下主题:①科技伦理的基础理论研究;②传统医疗卫生与健康政策的伦理研究;③新兴科技伦理风险识别及治理研究。
Abstract：This study uses a sample of 1098 papers from the Web of Science Core Collection published from 2003 to 2023,employing bibliometrics and visualization methods to analyze the international research hotspots and evolution trends in science and technology ethics.The results showed that overall,international ethical research on science and technology showed a continuous upward trend,roughly going through four development stages.The main international research forces of science and technology ethics are distributed in the United States and the United Kingdom,and China ranks in the top ten,although it is relatively low in the rankings,its influence is also constantly increasing.In the past 20 years,research hotspots have focused on three main themes:the first one is basic theoretical ethical research on science and technology;the second one is ethical research on traditional healthcare and health policies;the third is research on the identification and governance of ethical risks in emerging science and technologies.
罗会宇, 陶应时. 科技伦理国际研究热点与演化[J]. 中国科技论坛, 2025(3): 141-151.
Luo Huiyu, Tao Yingshi. International Research Hotspots and Evolution of Science and Technology Ethics. , 2025(3): 141-151.
[1]RENZONG Q.Conceptual issues in ethics of science and technology[J].Studies in Logic and the Foundations of Mathematics,1995,134(06):537-551. [2]LEINO-KILPI H,TUOMAALA U.Research ethics and nursing science:An empirical example[J].Journal of Advanced Nursing,1989,14(6):451-458. [3]DHAKAL R K.Responsible practice of research:Safeguarding research integrity and publication ethics[J].Journal of Education and Research,2018,6(2):1-11. [4]王海花,杜梅.数字创新国际研究热点与演化:一个可视化分析[J].科技进步与对策,2021,38(21):152-160. [5]ALLEN L B.Justice as measure of nongovernmental organization success in postdisaster community assistance[J].Science,Technology,Human Values,2013,38(2):224-249. [6]BOGNER A,TORGERSEN H.Different ways of problematising biotechnology—and What it means for technology governance[J].Public Underst Science.2015;24(5):516-532. [7]HONKELA N,TOIKKA A,HUKKINEN J,et al.Coming to grips with scientific ignorance in the governance of endocrine disrupting chemicals and nanoparticles[J].Environmental Science & Policy,2014(38):154-163. [8]KEULARTZ J,SCHERMER M,KORTHALS M,et al.Ethics in technological culture:A programmatic proposal for a pragmatist approach[J].Science,Technology,Human Values,2004,29(1):3-29. [9]MATHIESON K.Towards a design science of ethical decision support[J].Journal of Business Ethics,2007,76,(3):269-292. [10]STILGOE J,OWEN R,MACNAGHTEN P.Developing a framework for responsible innovation[J].Research Policy,2013,42(9):1568-1580. [11]KATIE S,SARA A.Blended,not bossy:Ethics roles,responsibilities and expertise in design[J].Interacting with Computers,2017,29(1):71-79. [12]INHORN M C,BIRENBAUM-CARMELI D.Assisted reproductive technologies and culture change[J].Annual Review of Anthropology,2008,37(1):177-196. [13]RHODES R.Medicine and contextual justice[J].Camb Q Healthc Ethics.2018,27(2):228-249. [14]HOFMANN B.EthicalIssues with colorectal cancer screening:A systematic review[J].Journal of Evaluation in Clinical Practice.2017,23(3):631-641. [15]BRILL S B,MOSS K O,PRATER L.Transformation of the doctor-patient relationship:Big data,accountable care,and predictive health analytics[J].HEC Forum.2019,31(4):261-282. [16]FUJIMORI M,SATO A,JINNO S,et al.Integrated communication support program for oncologists,caregivers and patients with rapidly progressing advanced cancer to promote patient-centered communication:J-support 1704 study[J].Journal of Clinical Oncology,2007,39(15):12119. [17]COOPER J.Problematising the ethics of organ donation after circulatory death in the UK[J].Critical Public Health,2017,27(4):499-505. [18]RANSE K,YATES P,COYER F.End-of-life care in the intensive care setting:A descriptive exploratory qualitative study of nurses'beliefs and practices[J].Aust Crit Care.2012,25(1):4-12. [19]TOMÁS C C,OLIVEIRA E,SOUSA D,et al.Proceedings of the 3rd IPLeiria's international health congress:Leiria,Portugal[J].BMC Health Services Research.2016,16(3):200. [20]SUK M,PARK Y S.A comparativezntention between South Korea and the United States:Social workers' perspective[J].Pogǒn Sahoe Yǒn'gu,2015,35(3):222-252. [21]SCHOPPER D,UPSHUR R,MATTHYS F,et al.Research ethics review in humanitarian contexts:The experience of the independent ethics review board of Médecins Sans Frontières[J].PLoS Medicine,2009,6(7):e1000115. [22]HAN Z,WANG J,ZHANG K,et al.The ethics of covid-19 clinical trials:New considerations in a controversial area[J].IntegrativeMedicine Research,2020,9(3):100425. [23]TEVAH P,JODYN P,DANIEL T,et al.Engaging a state:Facebook comments on a large population biobank[J].Journal of Community Genetics,2017,8(3):183-197. [24]TOWNSEND A B.Human genome editing:How to prevent rogue actors[J].BMC Medical Ethics,2020,21(1):95. [25]KAEBNICK G E,GUSMANO M K,MURRAY T H.The ethics of synthetic biology:Next steps and prior questions[J].Hastings Center Report,2014,44(6):S4-S26. [26]LINTON D J,WALSH T S.Introduction to the field of nanotechnology ethics and policy[J].Journal of Business Ethics,2012,109(4):547-549. [27]CORLEY E A,KIM Y,SCHEUFELE D A.Scientists' ethical obligations and social responsibility for nanotechnology research[J].Science and Engineering Ethics,2016,22(1):111-132. [28]LIANA B,MARTINA D,JAMES G.A Four-part working bibliography of neuroethics:Part 1 overview and reviews—defining and describing the field and its practices[J].Philosophy,Ethics,and Humanities in Medicine:PEHM,2014,9(1):9. [29]BELL E,RACINE E.Ethics guidance for neurological and psychiatric deep brain stimulation[J].Handbook of Clinical Neurology,2013,116(116C):313-325. [30]LAJAUNIE C,SCHAFER B,MAZZEGA P.Big data enters environmental Law[J].Transnational Environmental Law,2019,8(3):523-545. [31]HUNT M,PRINGLE J,CHRISTEN M,et al.Ethics of emergent information and communication technology applications in humanitarian medical assistance[J].International Health,2016,8(4):239-245. [32]SAMPLE M,SATTLER S,BLAIN-MORAES S,et al.Do publics share experts' concerns about brain-computer interfaces? A trinational survey on the ethics of neural technology[J].Science,Technology,Human Values,2020,45(6):1242-1270. [33]KIM J,SON Y H.An Exploratory study on the research trend of artificial intelligence ethics[J].Journal of Multiculture and Education.2022,6(2):191-223.
2025, 
