Abstract：Convenient private manufacturing and the digital trends of patents’ expressions in the era of 3D printing may trigger large-scale,geographically dispersed patent infringement.Existing exclusive measures,“ex post sue”or“ex ante review”,raise the operating cost of the patent system sharply and intensify the contradiction between right holders and the public.By forming patent compensation system,private manufacturing behavior separated from the original uncertainty of the legal status.The patent compensation system brings printed materials in the object of compensation and shares the compensation according to the market which is reflected by the CAD drawing download flow.The patent compensation system can meet the two-way needs:the public can carry out private manufacturing conveniently,participate in innovation,and the patentee can obtain the full remuneration.
孟奇勋, 李靖. 3D打印时代数字化专利侵权及补偿机制研究[J]. 中国科技论坛, 2017(9): 153-160.
Meng Qixun,Li Jing. Digital Patent Infringement and Compensation System in the Era of 3D Printing. , 2017(9): 153-160.
[1] MARKILLIE P.A third industrial revolution[R].The Economist,April 21,2012. [2]HOLBROOK T,OSBORN L.Digital patent infringement in an era of 3D printing[J].UC davis law review,2015(48):1319-1385. [3]刘鑫,余翔.3D打印技术对专利实施的潜在挑战与对策思考[J].科技进步与对策,2015(10):101-106. [4]MALAQUIAS P.The 3D printing revolution:an intellectual property analysis[J].2014-08-08.https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2495416. [5]LEMLEY M.IP in a world without scarcity[J].New York university law review,2015(02):460-515. [6]KURMAN M.Carrots not sticks:rethinking enforcement of intellectual property rights for 3D-printed manufacturing[R].3D Printing and Additive Manufacturing,2014(1):44-51. [7]BRADSHAW S,Bowyer A,Hauf P.The intellectual property implications of low-cost 3D printing[J].Scripted,2010(01):6-31. [8]FINOCCHIARO C.Personal factory or catalyst for piracy:the hype,hysteria,and hard realities of consumer 3-D printing[J].Cardozo arts & entertainment law journal,2013(02):473-508. [9]MOSCARITOLO A.Defcad,the‘Pirate Bay’of 3D printing,seeks funding[EB/OL].PC Magazine,2013-03-13.http://www.pcmag.com/article2/0,2817,2416559,00.asp. [10]BREAN D.Patenting physibles:a fresh perspective for claiming 3D-printable products[J].Santa clara law review,2015(04):838-863. [11]OSBORN L,PEARCE J,HASELHUHN A.A case for weakening patent rights[J].St.john’s law review.2015,(04):1185-1253. [12]刘强,冯晓青,武志孝.3D打印给知识产权保护带来冲击[N].检察日报,2015-01-15(3). [13]杨萌,郑志柱.专利间接侵权与专利侵权判定原则[J].知识产权,2011,(04):55-58. [14]刘强,王超.3D打印视野下的专利间接侵权——兼评《专利法修改草案(征求意见稿)》第71条之规定[J].电子知识产权,2015(05):29-34. [15]伍春艳.试论3D打印技术背景下专利间接侵权的认定[J].华中科技大学学报(社会科学版),2014(05):77-80. [16]吴广海.3D打印中的专利权保护问题[J].知识产权,2014(07):17-22. [17]DESAI D,MAGLIOCCA G.Patents,meet Napster:3D printing and the digitization of things[J].Georgetown law journal,2013(06):1691-1720. [18]OSBORN L.Of PhDs,pirates,and the public:three-dimensional printing technology and the arts[J].Texas A&M law review,2014(01):811-835. [19]HOLBROOK T R,OSBORN L.Digital patent infringement in an era of 3D printing[J].UC davis law review,2015(48):1319-1385. [20]LIDDICOAT J,NIELSEN J,NICOL D.Three dimensions of patent infringement:liability for creation and distribution of CAD files[J].Australian intellectual property journal,2016(26):165-178. [21]杨延超.3D打印挑战知识产权[N].经济参考报,2013-08-27(8). [22]MACIK T.Global data meets 3-D printing:the quest for a balanced and globally collaborative solution to prevent patent infringement in the foreseeable 3-D Printing revolution[J].Indiana journal of global legal studies,2015(01):149-173. [23]BREAN D.Asserting patents to combat infringement via 3D printing:It’s no use[J].Fordham intellectual property,media & entertainment law journal,2013,(03):771-814. [24]温欣,刘兹恒.数字时代私人复制的版权补偿金制度改革趋势[J].图书与情报,2014(13):18-21. [25]秦珂.基于补偿金制度的P2P技术版权问题解决模式分析[J].图书与情报,2012(04):52-55. [26]Outlook of mergers & acquisitions,investments,and Patents in 3D Printing Market[R].June 16,2016.http://www.marketsandmarkets.com/Market-Reports/3d-printing-market-m-a-249030598.html. [27]张今.数字环境下的版权补偿金制度[J].政法论坛,2010(01):80-87. [28]曾昆.3D打印的材料之殇[J].新材料产业,2014(10):39-41. [29]黄亮.3D打印著作权问题探讨[J].现代出版,2015(02):24-27. [30]李涤尘,苏秦,卢秉恒.增材制造——创新与创业的利器[J].航空制造技术,2015(10):40-43. [31]MENDIS D,SECCHI D,REEVES P.A legal and empirical study into the intellectual property implications of 3D printing[R].2015-04-29.https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/3d-printing-research-reports.
2017, 
